1. **Subject matter of the dispute:** The prosecutor filed a lawsuit with the court seeking to invalidate a gas mask supply contract concluded as a result of a tender due to anti-competitive concerted practices by the participants, and to apply the consequences of invalidity of the transaction in the form of recovery of funds into…
1. The subject matter of the dispute is the prosecutor's claim to invalidate a supply contract concluded as a result of a public procurement due to anti-competitive concerted practices by the participants and the application of consequences of the invalidity of a legal transaction that contradicts the interests of the state.
2. In this case, the…
This judgment, *Kılıçarslan and Others v. Türkiye* (2026), concerns 595 applications from individuals convicted of membership in the “FETÖ/PDY” armed terrorist organization following the 2016 coup attempt in Türkiye. The core issue is that these convictions were based primarily on the applicants’ use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock,” which domestic courts treated as sufficient,…
The case of *Elezi v. Albania* (Application no. 17141/21) concerns the dismissal of a career prosecutor following the extraordinary transitional vetting process implemented in Albania to reform the justice system. The applicant, who had served as a prosecutor since 1999, was removed from office by the Special Appeal Chamber (SAC) due to alleged discrepancies in…
The judgment in *Dönmez and Others v. Türkiye* (2026) addresses a series of applications concerning convictions for membership in the “FETÖ/PDY” organization following the 2016 coup attempt in Türkiye. The core issue before the Court was the domestic judicial practice of relying decisively on the use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock” as sufficient, automatic…
This judgment in the case of *Malachini and Others v. Russia* (Applications nos. 9184/09 and 22580/10) addresses the responsibility of the Russian Federation for the torture and killing of Georgian prisoners of war during and immediately following the 2008 armed conflict. The Court confirmed that the applicants, who were Georgian servicemen, fell under Russia’s "spatial…
The judgment in *Karchava v. Georgia* (application no. 34790/23) addresses the limits of state interference with solo protests. The applicant, a psychotherapist, was arrested and detained for 24 hours after attempting to set up a tent for a hunger strike near a public statue to protest the lack of school lunches. Despite the peaceful nature…
Greetings. As a lawyer with many years of experience, I have analyzed the Supreme Court decision you provided. Here is the detailed analysis:
1. **Subject matter of the dispute:** The plaintiff sought to declare the inaction of the Office of the Prosecutor General regarding the non-payment of his severance pay upon dismissal as unlawful and to…
1. **Subject of the Dispute:** A judge’s challenge against a decision by the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine (HQCJ) declaring the judge unfit for the position held, in a situation where the submission for dismissal was not considered by the High Council of Justice (HCJ) due to the judge reaching the mandatory retirement…
Here is the detailed analysis of the court decision, prepared in accordance with your requirements:
1. **Subject Matter of the Dispute:** Recovery of debt under a loan agreement from the borrower’s legal successors, including inflationary losses and 3% per annum calculated on the basis of Article 625 of the Civil Code of Ukraine following the adoption…
Here is the analysis of this court decision, prepared for your material:
1. The subject of the dispute is the right of the family members of a serviceman who died from a disease while performing military service duties to receive a one-time financial assistance in the amount of UAH 15,000,000, as provided for by Resolution of…
The following is a detailed analysis of the court judgment, prepared from a professional perspective:
1. **Subject of the Dispute:** Challenging the Pension Fund's refusal to recalculate the monthly lifetime judicial allowance of a retired judge based on a certificate of judicial remuneration calculated taking into account the subsistence minimum established as of January 1, 2024.
2.…
1. **Subject matter of the dispute:** The prosecutor appealed to the court with a claim to cancel the results of the auction and the permits for subsoil use issued to Cherembud LLC due to the absence of a mandatory environmental impact assessment report.
2. **Arguments of the Court:** The Supreme Court emphasized that the state participates…
Here is a detailed analysis of the court decision, prepared from a professional standpoint:
1. The subject of the dispute is a lawsuit filed by a tax authority seeking to invalidate a supply agreement and apply the consequences of its invalidity due to the alleged fictitious nature of business transactions and the creation of an illegal…
Here is the analysis of this court decision:
1. The subject of the dispute is the lawfulness of the return of an appellate complaint due to non-payment of the court fee for filing an appeal against a court ruling on the refusal to accept an application for the establishment of judicial control over the enforcement of…
Greetings. As a lawyer with many years of experience, I have analyzed the court decision you provided. Here is a concise and professional analysis for your material:
1. **Subject matter of the dispute:** The plaintiff sought to have a Ministry of Justice order, which had cancelled a notary’s decision on the state registration of ownership rights…
1. **Subject matter of the dispute:** The Rivne City Council filed a lawsuit to eliminate obstacles in the use of a land plot by demolishing an unauthorized non-residential building and cancelling the state registration of ownership rights to it.
2. **Court’s arguments:**
- The court confirmed that the disputed premises constitute unauthorized construction, as…
This United Nations Convention against Cybercrime represents a landmark global effort to harmonize criminal justice responses to the misuse of information and communications technology (ICT) systems. It establishes a comprehensive framework for criminalizing specific cyber-offenses, facilitating international cooperation, and providing mutual legal assistance to combat transnational cybercrime. By creating common legal standards, the Convention aims…
This judgment, *Yeryomenko v. Ukraine* (application no. 8394/20), concerns a grave case of systemic torture within the Ukrainian penitentiary system, specifically at Oleksiyivska Prison no. 25 in Kharkiv. The applicant, who was detained between 2011 and 2015, alleged that he was subjected to prolonged physical abuse, including beatings with rubber truncheons and cigarette burns to…
The case of *Samanyuk v. Ukraine* (Application no. 65686/17) concerns a dispute over the ownership of land purchased by the applicant from local authorities in 2002, which was later invalidated because the land fell within a railway exclusion zone. The national courts ruled in favor of the railway company, Ukrzaliznytsya, relying on historical technical documentation…