Here is the translation of the legal analysis:
1. Subject of Dispute: Invalidation of JSC “Poltavaoblenergo” decision on additional charging for unaccounted electrical energy based on seal damage at the metering point.
2. Key Court Arguments:
– During inspection, damage to the PPKO seal on the metering cabinet was discovered
– Expert examination recorded traces of thermal and mechanical impact on the seal
– Contractual relations exist between parties regarding electricity distribution
– Previous courts considered the additional charging legitimate
3. Supreme Court Decision: Revoke decisions of previous instances and refer the case for new consideration due to improper evaluation of evidence regarding seal damage.
Important: – The court deviated from previous practice in assessing expert investigations of seal damages.
