1. **Subject matter of the dispute:** Recovery of inflationary losses and 3% per annum from SE "Guaranteed Buyer" in favor of JSC "NNEGC "Energoatom" for late payment for electrical energy for the period of 2021–2025.
2. **Key arguments of the court:**
- The courts of lower instances incorrectly applied the concept of prejudice (the…
Greetings. As a lawyer with many years of experience, I have analyzed the court decision you provided. Here is a detailed analysis:
1. **Subject of the dispute:** Recovery of over 17 million UAH from an electricity producer (PE "Natsprod") in favor of JSC "Guaranteed Buyer" as overpaid funds for electricity which, according to updated metering data,…
1. **Subject matter of the dispute:** Challenging by the debtor (Peasant Farm "Zolotyj Zhaivir") the actions and inaction of the state enforcement officer regarding the compulsory recovery of funds in enforcement proceedings initiated after the commencement of bankruptcy proceedings for this debtor.
2. **Main arguments of the court:**
- The court emphasized the priority…
1. **Subject of the dispute:** Review of the liquidator's motion to impose subsidiary liability on the head and deputy director for causing the bankruptcy of an agricultural enterprise.
2. **Court's arguments:**
- The Supreme Court emphasized that imposing subsidiary liability under Article 61 of the Code of Ukraine on Bankruptcy Procedures requires establishing…
Here is a detailed analysis of the court decision, prepared in accordance with your request:
**1. Subject matter of the dispute**
The subject matter of the dispute is the legality of the termination of appellate proceedings initiated by a tax authority against a court of first instance ruling on the approval of the liquidator's report and the…
1. **Subject of the dispute:** Challenging by the taxpayer (Private Agricultural Enterprise "NOVE ZHYTTIA") of tax notices-decisions by which the controlling authority assessed additional tax liabilities and penalties due to the alleged lack of underlying commercial substance of transactions, failure to substantiate expenses, and violation of deadlines for the registration of tax invoices.
2. **Court's arguments:**
…
Case No. 991/5014/24 dated 18/06/2026
Greetings. As a lawyer with many years of experience, I have analyzed the court decision provided by you. Here is a detailed analysis:
1. The subject of the dispute is the legality of the court of first instance’s refusal to lift the interim measures imposed on assets seized as state revenue pursuant…
Here is the detailed analysis of the court decision, prepared in accordance with your request:
1. The subject of the dispute is the prosecutor’s claim for the vacation of an unauthorized occupied land plot of communal ownership through the demolition of an object of unauthorized construction (a cafeteria) and the return of the land plot to…
Here is the detailed analysis of the court decision, prepared in accordance with your instructions:
1. The subject of the dispute is the lawfulness of the refusal by the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine to pay the family members of a deceased service member a one-time monetary allowance in the amount of UAH 15,000,000, as provided…
The following is a detailed analysis of the court decision, prepared from a professional perspective:
1. **Subject of the dispute:** The dispute concerns the lawfulness of the refusal by the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine to pay a one-time monetary assistance (OMA) in the amount of UAH 15 million to the family of a deceased serviceman…
Case No. 379/1166/24 dated 06/10/2026
Below is a detailed analysis of the court decision prepared from a professional standpoint:
1. **Subject of the dispute:** Challenging the actions of a state enforcement officer regarding the premature termination of enforcement proceedings due to the debtor's alleged full compliance with the court decision on including a building in the plans…
Greetings. As a lawyer with many years of experience, I have analyzed the court decision you provided. Here is a brief analysis for your material:
1. **Subject of the dispute:** Invalidation of gift and sale-purchase agreements for real estate, which the plaintiff considers fraudulent (executed by the debtor for the purpose of evading the fulfillment of…
Here is a detailed analysis of the court decision, prepared in accordance with your request:
1. The subject of the dispute is the question of the possibility of appellate review of an investigating judge's ruling on the vacating of property seizure, which the court of appeal refused to review due to the formal absence of such…
1. **Subject matter of the dispute:** The dispute concerns the legality of the privatization of a former school building, which the public prosecutor's office is seeking to return to communal ownership by declaring the purchase and sale agreement invalid.
2. **Court's arguments:**
- The Supreme Court emphasized that the key criterion for determining jurisdiction…
1. **Subject of the dispute:** The plaintiffs appealed to the court with a request to recognize the absence of the defendant’s (Olymp-Agro LLC) leasehold right to the land plots, on the grounds that the lease agreements were concluded without the expression of will of the testator, which was confirmed by the conclusion of a forensic…
1. **Subject of the dispute:** The case concerns the invalidation of a land lease agreement, the transfer of rights and obligations of a buyer under a land sale and purchase agreement, and counterclaims for the cancellation of the state registration of the lease agreement due to the denial of the fact of its signing by…
Here is a detailed analysis of this court decision, prepared for you:
1. **Subject matter of the dispute:** Declaration of invalidity of a residential house purchase and sale agreement as a fraudulent transaction executed by the debtor to the detriment of a creditor for the purpose of avoiding foreclosure on property.
2. **Arguments of the Court:**
…
Case No. 718/1563/21 dated 06/16/2026
Greetings. As a lawyer with many years of experience, I have analyzed the Supreme Court judgment provided by you. Here is a detailed analysis for your material:
1. **Subject of the dispute:** Removal of impediments to the use of a land plot through the restoration of boundary markers and the dismantling of…
Here is a detailed analysis of the court decision, prepared from a professional perspective.
1. The subject of the dispute is the lawfulness of the refusal by the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine to pay a one-time financial assistance in the amount of UAH 15,000,000 to a family member of a deceased serviceman, whose death occurred…
1. **Subject Matter of the Dispute:** The plaintiff sought through the court to declare the inaction of the balance holder (the State Audit Service) unlawful and to compel it to initiate the transfer of a service apartment into communal ownership for subsequent privatization.
2. **Court's Arguments:**
- The Supreme Court emphasized that a…