Here is the translation:
1. Subject of Dispute: Recovery of debt in the amount of USD 535,000 under a loan agreement between PERSON_1 and PERSON_3.
2. Main Arguments of the Court:
The Supreme Court paid special attention to the principles of good faith and reasonableness in civil proceedings. The court identified signs of artificiality in the claim, which may be aimed not at protecting rights but at complicating the division of joint marital property. In particular, the court pointed out the dubious behavior of the parties – relatives who may be attempting to conceal property and create artificial debts.
The court emphasized that participants in legal proceedings must act in good faith and not use judicial proceedings for “procedural games” or manipulations.
3. Court Decision: The Cassation Court satisfied the cassation appeals of PERSON_4, revoked the ruling of the appellate court on closing the appellate proceedings, and referred the case for a new review to the appellate instance.
