[:uk]
Analysis of the Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine No. 4013-IX dated October 9, 2024
Adoption of the Draft Law in Principle
The Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine resolves to adopt in principle the draft Law of Ukraine on amendments to the Criminal Code of Ukraine and the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine. These amendments aim to improve the regulation of plea agreements in criminal proceedings, particularly concerning corruption-related criminal offenses and offenses connected with corruption. The draft law, registered under number 12039, was submitted by Member of Parliament D.H. Arahamiya and other Members of Parliament.
Revision of the Draft Law by the Committee
The resolution also stipulates that the Committee of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on Law Enforcement Activities must revise the aforementioned draft law. This revision should take into account the amendments and proposals from subjects of the right to legislative initiative. Furthermore, a reduced timeframe for submitting such amendments and proposals is established, halved from the standard period. Upon completion of the revision, the Committee must submit the draft law for the second reading in the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine.
Signature and Date
The resolution is signed by the Chairman of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine R. Stefanchuk and dated October 9, 2024. This is an official document confirming the initial stage of consideration of the draft law aimed at improving legislative regulation in the sphere of combating corruption.
Consequences:
Description of the Consequences of Adopting the Legislative Act
The adoption of the draft Law of Ukraine on amendments to the Criminal Code and the Criminal Procedure Code may have a significant impact on the legal system of the country, particularly in the context of combating corruption. This decision, on the one hand, offers opportunities for improving the effectiveness of justice, while on the other hand, it poses a threat to some of its principles.
Positive Consequences
One of the key advantages is the simplification of the process of entering into plea agreements. This could reduce the duration of criminal proceedings and expedite the accountability of the guilty parties. Additionally, the new mechanism may increase the likelihood of cooperation with individuals possessing crucial information about corruption offenses, which in turn could lead to more effective investigations.
Moreover, the improved legislation could foster a more transparent legal environment, enhancing citizens’ trust in state institutions. The reduction of the deadlines for submitting amendments will allow for timely responses to changes in society and legal practice.
Negative Consequences
Despite the positive aspects, there are risks associated with a potential deterioration of the corruption situation. The introduction of new mechanisms may encourage individuals to commit corruption offenses, as the possibility of evading serious punishment in exchange for cooperation could foster irresponsible behavior.
Furthermore, the changes may lead to a decline in public trust in law enforcement agencies, as society may perceive this as an attempt to legitimize corruption. The absence of appropriate punishment could create an atmosphere of impunity.
Another important issue is the transparency of justice. The introduction of plea agreements may lead to abuses and manipulations, negatively affecting the image of justice in Ukraine. Unpredictability in law enforcement may threaten the business environment, deterring potential investors due to uncertainty.
Finally, there is a risk of human rights violations, as individuals may be coerced into admitting guilt under pressure, which contradicts the principles of a fair trial.
Thus, the adoption of this draft law carries both positive and negative consequences, and its implementation will require careful monitoring and assessment to ensure fairness and effectiveness of justice in Ukraine.[:]
