Subject of the dispute - challenging the decision of the High Council of Justice in a lawsuit filed by an individual. Since the available text contains only the introductory and operative parts of the resolution, without the reasoning part, it is impossible to determine the arguments that guided the court in making its decision.
The Grand…
The court was guided by the fact that an application for review of a court decision based on newly discovered circumstances may be filed no later than three years from the day the decision entered into legal force. Since the decision entered into legal force on December 5, 2018, and the application was filed only…
The court, in rendering its decision, was guided by the fact that the High Qualification Commission of Judges (HQCJ) considered the issue of including the judge's application in the agenda of the plenary session, but the commission members voted against its inclusion. The court noted that to recognize inaction as unlawful, the mere fact of…
Subject of the dispute - challenging the acts of the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine and its inaction. Unfortunately, it is impossible to determine the main arguments of the court from the provided text, as only the introductory and operative parts of the decision are presented, without the reasoning part, where the legal…
Here's a concise review of the key legal acts:
Emergency Market Procedures
Two major acts establish emergency procedures for product conformity during market crises:
- A Regulation amending 6 existing EU regulations for construction products, cableways, protective equipment, gas appliances, product safety and machinery
- A Directive modifying 10 existing directives covering outdoor equipment, machinery, pressure equipment, electromagnetic…
This judgment concerns the interpretation of Directive 2019/1023 on restructuring and insolvency, particularly regarding discharge of debt provisions. The essence of the judgment is that it clarifies how Member States can implement derogations from debt discharge rules. The Court ruled that while Member States have discretion to restrict access to debt discharge beyond what's explicitly…
This judgment concerns the interpretation of EU consumer protection law, specifically regarding unfair terms in consumer contracts and the principle of res judicata (finality of court decisions). The case arose from a dispute between a debt collection company and a consumer in Romania regarding unfair terms in a credit agreement.The judgment's structure consists of three…
This judgment concerns the admissibility of a preliminary ruling request from a Polish Supreme Court judge regarding judicial independence requirements. The key aspects are:The case originated from competition law fines imposed on several companies in Poland. During the proceedings, one company challenged the independence of a judge appointed based on a resolution of the new…
The judgment concerns the interpretation of EU legislation regarding compensation to victims of violent intentional crimes, specifically in cases of homicide. Here are the key points:Essence of the act: The Court ruled on whether EU law allows Member States to establish a tiered compensation scheme that excludes certain family members from receiving compensation based solely…
Essence of the Act This is a comprehensive technical regulation updating the EU's control list of dual-use items (items that can be used for both civilian and military purposes). The regulation specifically modifies Annex I of Regulation (EU) 2021/821, providing detailed technical specifications and control parameters for various sensitive materials, equipment, and technologies. It represents…
This Directive aims to streamline and simplify reporting requirements across several EU directives related to food safety, outdoor noise, healthcare, and radio equipment. It modifies four existing directives to reduce administrative burdens while maintaining policy objectives, targeting a 25% reduction in reporting requirements.The Directive's structure includes amendments to four key EU directives:Directive 1999/2/EC on food…
This Directive amends ten existing EU Directives related to product safety and conformity assessment to establish emergency procedures during internal market crises. The key aspects include:The Directive introduces new provisions for crisis situations when certain goods are designated as 'crisis-relevant'. It establishes procedures for expedited conformity assessment and market access for such goods during an…
The Internal Market Emergency and Resilience Act (IMERA) establishes a comprehensive framework for anticipating, preparing for and responding to crises affecting the EU internal market. It aims to safeguard the free movement of goods, services and persons, ensure availability of critical goods and services, and prevent disruptions to the internal market during emergencies. The Act…
This Regulation amends several EU regulations to establish emergency procedures for product conformity assessment and market surveillance during internal market emergencies. The key aspects include:The Regulation introduces changes to six existing EU regulations covering construction products, cableway installations, personal protective equipment, gas appliances, general product safety, and machinery to enable faster market access for crisis-relevant…
1. INDIVIDUAL_1 challenged the decision of the High Council of Justice to deny his claims.
2. The plaintiff, INDIVIDUAL_1, requested the annulment of the decision of the High Council of Justice, while the defendant, the High Council of Justice, defended the legality of its decision.
3. The courts of previous instances denied INDIVIDUAL_1's claim and upheld the…
December 5, 2018, and the three-year period for filing an application for review based on newly discovered circumstances ended on December 5, 2021; since the application was submitted in July 2024.
Appeal Against the Inaction of the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine (HQCJ) Regarding the Non-Consideration of Judge PERSON_1's Application for the Dismissal of Commission Member PERSON_2 Due to Gross Negligence of Duties.
2. The parties in the case were Judge PERSON_1, who believed that the HQCJ violated her rights by not properly considering her…
Higher Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine, recognition of its inaction as unlawful, and obligation of the Commission to perform certain actions.
The parties in the case were the plaintiff, INDIVIDUAL_1, who demanded the annulment of the Commission's acts and to compel it to act, and the defendant, the Higher Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine,…
The subject of the dispute was the **nullification of the results of a state procurement and the contract for the capital repair of a military canteen** in the city of Poltava.
The prosecution, in the interest of the **Ministry of Defense of Ukraine**, claimed that the procurement was conducted **with violations**, while the defendants — the…
EU Legislation Analysis
Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/2776
This regulation amends the notification forms used in the EU merger control process to correct inaccuracies and ensure consistency with Council Regulation (EC) No 139/2004. Key amendments include updates to definitions, formats, and requirements, particularly regarding "affected markets" and electronic submissions. These adjustments improve clarity and transparency in…
